News / Sports / A trophy for St. Louis, a turning point for CITY SC

A trophy for St. Louis, a turning point for CITY SC

Daniel Edelman’s winning penalty rewarded thousands of traveling supporters and gave CITY another milestone in a memorable season.

On Wednesday night, St. Louis CITY SC found a little slice of home during the U.S. Open Cup final in Columbus, Ohio. CITY red jerseys dotted the sold-out ScottsMiracle-Gro Stadium, and chants of “S-T-L” could be heard at times. The environment was fitting for a final, with dueling chants from Columbus Crew supporters (known as “The Nordecke”) and more than 2,000 traveling St. Louis supporters.

The Crew peppered CITY with attempts, outshooting St. Louis 15–3 at full time. Yet CTY captain and starting goalkeeper Roman Bürki kept the game scoreless, before being injured in the 70th minute after a collision with Mo Farsi. As Bürki was stretchered off the pitch, fans chanted his name and cheered as he waved to the crowd.

Are you a CITY SC fan?

Subscribe to the CITY Scene newsletter to get a fan’s guide to the pro soccer scene in St. Louis.

We will never send spam or annoying emails. Unsubscribe anytime.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

“Roman was a hero,” teammate Daniel Edelman later said. “He put his body on the line for us. We knew we had to step up for our captain.”

In stepped backup keeper Ben Lundt, one of just three CITY subs throughout the game. It was Lundt who provided a key opportunity by stopping a crucial penalty kick from the Crew’s Santí Rodriguez after a grueling 120-minute game ending in penalty kicks.

Finally, after four rounds of PKs, Edelman stood in front of the goal with a chance to win CITY’s first trophy. The 23-year-old midfielder may have seemed like an unlikely hero, having arrived from Red Bull New York earlier this year. The defensive midfielder isn’t usually the first name on the scoresheet, though he’s excelled in high-pressure PKs, including Red Bull’s win in 2024 over the defending MLS champion Columbus Crew.

Ignoring The Nordecke’s shouts, Edelman stepped up, stared down goalkeeper Nick Hagglund, and smashed his shot to the opposite side of the diving keeper. The ball hit the back of the net.

Edelman turned and sprinted toward St. Louis supporters, darting past a joyous Lundt. “Ben was never catching me,” Edelman later joked. “I’m too fast for him.”

After 120 minutes of battling beside teammates Chris Durkin and Carlo Holse in the midfield, Edelman levitated as he ripped his shirt off and waved it over his head. “I was cramping so bad by the time everyone was down there celebrating with me,” Edelman recalled. “I could barely stand on the podium.”

Edelman’s adoration for the traveling support echoed throughout the squad.

“We have something special here,” CITY manager Yoann Damet said afterward. “You see it when we’re at home. You see it when we travel. And I hope we have given them a moment to remember.”

As CITY players piled around Edelman, the coaching staff sprinted toward the action. Damet leaped in the air, pumping his fist toward the mass of CITY fans.

“You look up there, see that, and they completely deserve to have this silverware,” Edelman said. 

As the dust settled and Champagne poured, CITY’s place in soccer history crystallized: The city of St. Louis has now won 11 U.S. Open Cup titles, with CITY continuing the legacy.

“It’s a special feeling,” Edelman said.


A beginning and an end

As the celebrations marched on, Timo Baumgartl reflected on the past year—the first under sporting director Corey Wray—and what’s ahead.

“This is something special for all of us, but it’s just the first step,” Baumgartl said. “We’re far from satisfied. We have a big game on Saturday.”

Wray watched as his longterm vision bore early fruit against his former club. The win sealed the club’s spot in next season’s CONCACAF Champions Cup—but CITY players are hungry for more as the Major League Soccer season continues.

“We’re still pushing for a top-four spot, still pushing for a home playoff series,” Baumgartl said. “We have to celebrate now, but we’re already thinking about Saturday.”

CITY will play Real Salt Lake in Utah, where St. Louis will most likely be without Alex Mățan and Burki, who rejoined the team on Thursday morning.

And when CITY returns to Energizer Park next Wednesday to host the Portland Timbers, St. Louis will raise the banner commemorating the U.S. Open Cup victory.