The stakes are high for Wednesday’s U.S. Open Cup final, featuring St. Louis CITY SC and the Columbus Crew in Columbus, Ohio.
It marks CITY’s first final, the club’s first real opportunity at silverware, and a chance to jumpstart a new era while adding to St. Louis’ storied history in U.S. Soccer’s longest-running competition.
Are you a CITY SC fan?
Subscribe to the CITY Scene newsletter to get a fan’s guide to the pro soccer scene in St. Louis.
From a record-setting unbeaten streak to a homecoming for CITY’s leadership, there are plenty of compelling storylines heading into the matchup. Here are five things to know.
1. CITY SC has turned its season around.
It’s been a remarkable turnaround for a CITY group that just set a record 21-match unbeaten streak.
The mentality was forged through early-season struggles as manager Yoann Damet established his system. Defensively, the structure came together, but the attack lagged. It took time to install the rotations and transform the team during a pivotal transfer window.
When CITY beat the Chicago Fire during the U.S. Open Cup’s round of 16 in late April, however, St. Louis seemed to turn a corner. “I think something happened,” CITY captain and goalkeeper Roman Bürki said. “We worked hard. We started from the bottom. We were not happy where we were at the beginning of the season, and we worked very hard, and we got rewarded.”
Following that win, CITY SC went 15-6-2, including a tense PK win over Houston in the U.S. Open Cup quarterfinals, as well as a 3-0 trouncing of the Colorado Rapids during the semifinals.
The competition has given CITY a lifeline when it needed it most. Now, the club has a chance to turn that momentum into its first trophy.
2. For CITY’s leadership, the final is a homecoming.
Sporting director Corey Wray and Damet are returning to the city where they both served as understudies during a period of unprecedented success for the Crew, one of the league’s original clubs.
Wray and Damet served as assistant general manager and assistant coach, respectively, for former Columbus Crew sporting director Tim Bezbatchenko and manager Wilfried Nancy.
Since then, sporting director Issa Tall has led the project after serving as assistant GM alongside Wray. After parting ways with former manager Henrik Rydström earlier this season, former Crew 2 manager Laurent Courtois has served as interim manager.
St. Louis fans may remember Courtois’s Crew 2 side as the 2022 MLS NEXT Pro champions, having defeated CITY2 in the competition’s inaugural final.
Four years later, the stakes are considerably higher, with Wray and Damet looking to bring home the first major trophy of CITY’s MLS era.
3. A St. Louis native stands in CITY’s way.
Among the familiar faces on the Columbus side is goalkeeper Patrick Schulte, whose soccer career has deep St. Louis roots.
The St. Louis native was Crew 2’s goalkeeper during that 2022 MLS NEXT Pro championship victory over CITY2, before becoming the Crew’s starting goalkeeper.
Columbus drafted the former Saint Louis University goalkeeper 12th overall in the 2022 draft, though Schulte had already tasted first-team soccer.
It was his time with St. Louis Scott Gallagher, and then STLFC, that saw him debut in the 2019 U.S. Open Cup in an early-round matchup against the Des Moines Menace. STLFC advanced thanks to a young Schulte’s heroics in the PK shootout, a performance that catapulted him into a U.S. Youth National Team call-up in 2020.
More than 1,500 St. Louis supporters are expected to make the trip to Columbus, but they won’t be cheering for the hometown goalkeeper this time around.
4. St. Louis has a storied history in the competition.
CITY will look to carry St. Louis’ U.S. Open Cup history into the modern era.
Ten U.S. Open Cup champions have emerged from the city’s competitive ranks, but it’s been nearly four decades since a St. Louis club has lifted the trophy.
In 1988, St. Louis Busch Seniors knocked off San Francisco’s Greek-Americans at Soccer Park to hoist the Dewar Trophy National Challenge Cup.
At the time, St. Louis felt like U.S. Soccer’s spiritual home. Fenton’s Soccer Park hosted multiple U.S. Open Cup finals and Concacaf Champions Cup matches in its first few years of operation, but no one on the pitch in June 1988 would have expected a nearly 40-year drought before a St. Louis soccer club had a chance to win the U.S. Open Cup again.
During a roundtable at Energizer Park on Monday, Busch Seniors alum John Hayes spoke about the expectations built from that success.
“When we went into a tournament like that, there was a lot of St. Louis pride on the line,” the St. Louis Soccer Hall of Famer recalled.
“It’s definitely something that makes the city very unique,” Damet said.
It would be fitting for CITY’s first trophy to bring the Gateway City’s historical success full circle—though Damet isn’t putting the cart before the horse.
“It’s a great story in the end, but it’s only a great story if on Wednesday we go out, compete, and perform the way we want,” he said.
5. For Bürki, the final could bring things full circle.
Bürki, a two-time German Cup (DFB Pokal) champion with Borussia Dortmund, knows that his team can’t let the weight of expectations set the tone.
“It’s the same game. It’s the same rules. It’s a normal game—there’s nothing special,” Bürki said. “The people around it make it special. The event makes it special.”
For the Swiss keeper, Wednesday’s final represents something more personal.
Bürki originally signed with St. Louis in hopes of creating a winning culture for the new club. Of course, there have been twists and turns along that journey over the past several years. When he committed to a new contract with CITY during a tumultuous time last fall, Bürki cited the club’s long-term vision as a reason that he wanted to stay.
No one could have predicted how quickly that vision would progress.
Wednesday’s final is an opportunity to check off the first step in a journey that Wray, Damet, and even Bürki hope leads to continental success. But first, it’s about bringing St. Louis soccer into the modern era.
“It’s a privilege to be in a final, playing for a trophy,” Bürki finished. “As soon as we step on the field, it’s a game that we play every weekend, every three days, and we are very good at the moment.”
The final kicks off Wednesday at 7 p.m. Central on Paramount+ and CBS Sports Network.