Plantain Girl Mandy Estrella and her partner, Bradley Payne, will be adding a Latin beat to the French, Italian, and continental vibe in Lafayette Square restaurants later this summer. Their newest venture, Mayo Ketchup, will bring the tastes of the islands to the neighborhood with a full menu of Puerto Rican, Dominican, and Cuban dishes at their fast-casual restaurant.
The two signed a lease on the 80-seat space formerly occupied by Laredo on Lafayette Square, a well-known Mexican restaurant that occupied the northwest corner of Park and Mississippi.
Find the best food in St. Louis
Subscribe to the St. Louis Dining In and Dining Out newsletters to stay up-to-date on the local restaurant and culinary scene.
“Mayo Ketchup is the pink fry sauce we serve with our tostones and other dishes—it’s a blend of mayonnaise and ketchup, with a few other ingredients,” explains Estrella of the condiment also known as “kitchen sauce” at some burger joints. The name is pronounced “MY-oh Ketchup,” the Puerto Rican way the ubiquitous condiment is pronounced on the islands. There are several versions of the sauce at international markets and a Heinz variation called Mayochup, available in larger groceries.
“I’ll be down at City Hall on Monday getting started with occupancy permits,” says Estrella. “We’ll have much more space in the kitchen, including a walk-in cooler and the ability to cook more specialties from the islands. We’ll be rebranding and doing simple renovations.” Estrella hopes to open the restaurant by late summer.
“The restaurant is in good shape, but we want to have an island feel to the space with plants and greenery,” she says. “It will be tropical but not tacky. We’re calling our creative friends in on this one to get the right look. I don’t just want to hang a Puerto Rican flag on the wall and call it branding.”
“We’ll be serving lunch and dinner in a fast-casual setting,” she says. “We want people to come in and order at the bar. We won’t have wait staff, but we will have people to ensure good hospitality and customer service.”
In the past, Estrella creatively tweaked tastes and made fusion bar dishes and dips to go with the beers and cocktails served in the spaces where they operated. The new restaurant will offer a bar program, and Estrella and Payne are applying for a liquor license, but the traditional dishes will be the main draw.

“We won’t be a late-night spot, and we won’t be having weekend brunch, but some of the items we made for brunches will show up as specials,” Estrella says. The most popular menu items will stay, such as the jibarito, a huge plantain sandwich, and mofongo, a mash of green plantains fried with salt, garlic, olive oil, and small bits of chicharrones served with a broth in combination with vegetables, seafood, or meat. There will also be bacalaitos, or salt cod fritters (“If a pancake and a fritter had a baby,” as Estrella puts it) and sorullitos, Puerto Rican corn fritters.
Visit Estrella’s Facebook page for updates.