News / Police Board agrees to pause action on double-digit raises—but only for two weeks

Police Board agrees to pause action on double-digit raises—but only for two weeks

Mayor Cara Spencer had pleaded for more time for the city to determine the true cost to its budget.

Mayor Cara Spencer won a rare—and minor—consession from the rest of the Board of Police Commissioners this morning when they voted to postpone a vote on double-digit raises for command staff.

Those proposed raises were announced Monday night, and Spencer swiftly decried them. Her concern was less about giving police commanders more pay and more about ancillary costs to the city, chiefly due to rules related to pay parity with the Fire Department. She said that because of the adjustments the city would then have to make to the fire department, the budget will be “out of sync.”

Get a fresh take on the day’s top news

Subscribe to the St. Louis Daily newsletter for a smart, succinct guide to local news from award-winning journalists Sarah Fenske and Ryan Krull.

We will never send spam or annoying emails. Unsubscribe anytime.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

“It’s so wildly disrespectful to every other department the city has to operate,” she said at Wednesday’s Police Board meeting.

Police Chief Robert Tracy, addressing the board, acknowledged, “Parity has held the department back from being competitive.”

Tracy and others with the St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department argued the big raises to top brass were warranted because the department’s ranks have seen “compression,” in which officers are currently taking a pay cut if they take a promotion to command staff. A lieutenant spoke about how he actually makes nearly the same salary as his subordinate, a sergeant, who is eligible for overtime. That sergeant, obviously, isn’t interested in a promotion that would mean more responsibility and no overtime. 

“This is not a fly by night analysis,” said a member of the police department’s budget staff.

“It feels like a fly by night analysis,” replied Spencer. As she previously noted, the Board announced the raises in a press release late Monday night with the expectation they’d be voted on Wednesday. Spencer criticized the proposal for not including a fiscal note calculating the overall cost to the city.

Spencer then proposed a motion to table the proposed raises. Board Attorney Chris Graville said that the postponement should include a specific date in which it would be taken up again. He suggested the board’s next meeting, June 17. If observers squinted, it almost looked for a moment like everyone was getting along.

By the time it passed, Spencer was decidedly cool on her own motion. She referenced several times that the only way to make this work for the city’s larger budget would involve “a time machine” going back several months and being more proactive about looping City Budget Director Paul Payne into budget conversations when there will be discussions that will affect other city departments: “It’s slightly less awful to the city.”

Even so, it represented a small victory for Spencer, who hasn’t gotten many when it comes to the Police Board. Commissioner Sonya Jenkins-Gray seconded her motion to postpone. She and Commissioners Brad Arteaga and Ed McVeigh then voted in favor of it, along with Spencer. Board President Chris Saracino voted present. Commissioner Don Brown is a non-voting member under state statute.

CORRECTION: A previous version of this story misstated the salary of the police lieutenant who spoke at the meeting compared to a sergeant.


Hear more about this story from Ryan Krull on The 314 Podcast.