One year and five months after finding itself in the path of a deadly tornado, the Boo Cat Club is looking sharp. Last weekend, staffers hosted the first event on site—a wedding—since 100-mph winds sent a giant sycamore crashing through the front of the building, ripping through brick like a pair of powerful scissors. Looking at it now, you’d never know just how badly the 119-year-old building had been damaged.
It helps that the 10,000 square-foot event space is owned by Pat and Carol Schuchard of Schuchard Projects, who are no strangers to tricky historic rehabs—even if this was their first tornado. A retired WashU art professor, Pat Schuchard is enamored with the building, which was designed by Louis Spiering as the first home of the St. Louis Artists’ Guild. “Tennessee Williams put on some of his first plays here,” he says of the theater, added in 1916. “Through 1970, they exhibited great artists: Max Beckmann, Thomas Hart Benton.”
Get a fresh take on the day’s top news
Subscribe to the St. Louis Daily newsletter for a smart, succinct guide to local news from award-winning journalists Sarah Fenske and Ryan Krull.
But when the Schuchards first acquired it, in 2013, the place was a wreck. It’s located in North City’s Academy neighborhood, which saw significant disinvestment in the 1960s and ‘70s. The artists’ guild had sold the building to a community-focused nonprofit in 1973, and what the Schuchards encountered suggested they were more focused more on their mission than building maintenance. A drop ceiling covered the skylight and “some of the most beautiful mold blooms you’ve ever seen,” Schuchard recalls. The couple got to work. “Of all our projects, this was probably the most complicated and the most time consuming,” he says.

Then, 12 years later, thanks to that tornado, they had to do it all over again. The second go-round brought its own frustrations—namely, insurance companies. They got a small check from their insurer at first (“to get you started,” Schuchard says they were told) but everything after that took months on end, which left their contractors waiting to get paid, too—even as the club had to refund fees from everyone whose events were canceled. “We’re still waiting for payments from the insurance company,” Schuchard says. “That’s been the hardest part of this.”
Says Brenden Kleiboeker, director of sales for Schuchard Projects, “We would have been open a long time ago if not for that. We would have been open by the first of the year!” And here’s a bitter irony: Now that they’ve fought tooth and nail to reopen, the insurer has tripled their rate.

The silver lining, perhaps, has been a chance to do things even better this time. The club isn’t just lovingly restored, but also beautifully reimagined. Pat Schuchard reworked some of his art pieces that were damaged and added others. The tornado has created some natural conversation pieces. When four of the terra cotta ornaments decorating the front of the building were broken, the Schuchards recast new ones and replaced them. Some big broken pieces from one, however, are on display in the upstairs bar—a visible symbol of what the century-old building recently endured.
And about those bars: Both are now such showstoppers that Schuchard wants to open them to the public. The basement bar, The Blue Bar, has its own entrance and a cool club feel; the bar on the mezzanine, called the Bow & Arrow, feels like a bar frequented by people in the know at an artsy boutique hotel. The illustrations that line the wall are ones that Schuchard found in 1920s clip art books by local Nutwood Publishing, as well as new ones he created to mimic the style. “I don’t think there are better drawings anywhere,” he says of the publisher’s clip art illustrations. After many were damaged in the tornado, he reworked them.

You can see both bars—and the post-tornado beauty of this old building—at the Boo Cat Club’s grand reopening, which will fill the entire weekend of October 23, no tickets required. (Hours are listed on Instagram.) They’re planning to take down some of the art now on the walls in order to facilitate a massive group show, just like the St. Louis Artists’ Guild used to do. Rockabilly band The Blue Sparks will play, with proceeds from the cash bars going to the neighboring Salt Covenant Baptist Church, which sits next door on Union Avenue.
The good news on this block isn’t limited to the Boo Cat Club’s reopening. It’s a collection of beautiful old buildings, with some of the finest churches in the city, and while the block was badly scarred by the tornado, signs of life abound everywhere. Across the street, the Union Avenue Christian Church has a whole new roof; it’s now open not only for Sunday services, but also performances of the Union Avenue Opera. And on both sides of the Boo Cat Club are churches that may look closed on first glance—but aren’t. To the south, Salt Covenant Baptist Church has plywood covering what had been a gorgeous stained glass window, but behind it, a vibrant congregation still gathers. Just north, Pilgrim Congregational Church UCC opened its newly renovated gymnasium in June.
Surveying the view from the Boo Cat Club’s front lawn, Pat Schuchard points at the front wall of the building. “There was a big gash down to here,” he says, gesturing about twelve feet high. “There was red tile everywhere” after it was ripped from the roof. The air-conditioning units were blown off the roof—and to this day he has no idea where they landed. “They were just gone,” he says. “You can’t even figure how some of this stuff happened.”
What you can figure out, if you’re Pat Schuchard, is how to move forward. The Boo Cat Club’s fourth phase starts now.