The owner of a South City gay bar accused of assaulting a police officer after a police SUV slammed into his bar is set to go to trial in two weeks—that is, if the case isn’t dismissed first.
Judge Rochelle Woodiest certainly seemed amenable to the case against Chad Morris not going to trial. She said she’d take the pending pretrial motions, including one for dismissal, under consideration. And she told prosecutor Rob Huq, “I think, however, you should talk to your office about next steps.” One of the potential next steps she specifically mentioned was a dismissal.
Get a fresh take on the day’s top news
Subscribe to the St. Louis Daily newsletter for a smart, succinct guide to local news from award-winning journalists Sarah Fenske and Ryan Krull.
The case against Chad Morris is nearly two years old. It began in December 2023 when a St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department SUV crashed into Bar:PM in the early hours of the morning. Officers quickly handcuffed co-owner James Pence, after which police say Morris, who is Pence’s husband and the bar’s other owner, assaulted one of the responding police officers. Headlines like this one from the New York Times—”Bar Owner Is Arrested After St. Louis Police Officer Crashes Into His Business”—generated a nationwide deluge of bad press for the department and city alike.
One of the charges against Morris has since been dropped. The trial, scheduled for November 12, would be for a misdemeanor assault against a police officer—a rare case of an extreme amount of prosecutorial and court resources being deployed for a lone misdemeanor charge. Perhaps not unrelated to that stubbornness, the city faces a lawsuit filed by Pence against two of the officers, alleging he was arrested without cause and put in fear of assault by the cops.
Yesterday’s hearing in the criminal matter was the final one scheduled prior to its trial.
Morris’ attorney Javad Khazaeli came prepared with a litany of gripes, most of which concerned a lack of evidence handed over from the police department to him. “I’m going into this trial blind,” he told Woodiest.
By way of example, Khazaeli said that he’d asked prosecutors to turn over the text messages for every officer on the scene. But Khazaeli had received only partial records for one officer who showed up on the scene late in the action. He said he knew further texts existed, because at least two officers said as much during depositions. The two officers who showed up and made the arrest as well as the two officers whose SUV slammed into the building? Khazaeli hadn’t gotten any texts from them.
What really matters is less that Khazaeli asked for those items but that Woodiest ordered two months ago that they be turned over—an order that Khazaeli says has been blatantly violated. That order, written on August 5, gave prosecutors 10 days to turn over statements drafted by two officers at the scene, text messages about the incident by “any officer who was present at the scene,” as well as written records by supervisors regarding the use of force against Morris.
Khazaeli says he’s gotten very few of those items, but it’s not prosecutors who are to blame. “The police department is hiding these documents,” he said.
Sgt. Sean Mazzola with the Police Department disputes Khazaeli’s assertions. “The SLMPD and our Legal Division have worked closely with the Circuit Attorney’s Office and have provided all requested evidence,” he told SLM via email.
The prosecutor on the case, Huq, himself said, “We’ve provided everything we got from the St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department.”
Huq did push back on Khazaeli for seemingly wanting to call officers with little to say about Morris’ alleged assault, seemingly to try to impeach them on the basis of text messages, internal affairs documents, or other material. He questioned the relevance of the text messages exchanged prior to the crash as it pertains to the alleged crime for which Morris would be standing trial.
Raymond Flojo, an attorney with the City Counselor’s Office who has represented the police department in this case for much of its duration, was not in court today. Last week, he filed paperwork with the court seeking to exit the case. Khazaeli said that Flojo has indicated he is leaving his job November 3.
Morris himself was in court for what he hoped was the final time in this criminal matter (his husband’s civil lawsuit against the department continues). “It sounds good,” he said afterwards, reflecting on the judge’s remarks. “We’re happy the judge is considering the dismissal. We hope that she will go with that. This has been a very long two years. It should have ended a long time ago. We are just hoping it will be over soon.”
Khazaeli somewhat sheepishly asked that if the judge were to grant his motion to dismiss, that she do it before the end of the day Friday, lest he spend all weekend prepping for a trial that doesn’t happen.