Sharon Howard puts down a drafting pencil and hurries to turn down the music. “I’m listening to my gospel,” she says, “keeping the evil spirits out and giving the building a blessing.”
She’s worked for Lonnie Tettaton for years, on a cobblestoned, dead-end street near the riverfront. They don’t get as many visitors as they used to; hand-painted signs have come to seem unnecessary.
Get a fresh take on the day’s top news
Subscribe to the St. Louis Daily newsletter for a smart, succinct guide to local news from award-winning journalists Sarah Fenske and Ryan Krull.
“In high school, I used to take the Grand streetcar down to Hadley Tech,” Tettaton recalls. “I’d look at all the signs. There were signs everywhere. I thought it’d be something good to get into.”
He studied commercial art, then apprenticed at G.C. Kern. “They don’t exist anymore.”
When he went into business for himself, he didn’t hesitate. “I sketched a sign that would put the name MERREL in an arch across a filling-station roof, went and got the job. Then I thought, ‘Now how do I get that arch across there?’ I was lost.” The space was about 60 feet high and 80 feet long, he adds, so each letter had to be about 9 feet high. “I made a center point, and then I tried to put lines. Didn’t know anything about geometry, but I had to figure out the angles.” He grins. “It came out good. Just like the gold leaf when I did my first gold-leaf job.”
That time, he sought the help of a master, E.C. Matthews. “He didn’t have a phone; people would come to him.” On a snowy day, Tettaton trudged over to Matthews’ studio and offered to split the job—which Tettaton had already accepted—if Matthews would show him how to do it. “He said, ‘You’re not going to get me out on a day like this, but I’ll show you how to do it.’”
Matthews showed him how to make a pattern; how to boil a gelatin capsule in water and make a size that would stick to the glass; how to rub a guilder’s tip on his hair (he had hair, then) and get enough static to lift a sheet of gold leaf without smudging it. “People used to do a lot of gold leaf,” Tettaton sighs, “on windows and glass. You’d wipe the excess gold away from the letters, then paint a shadow under them.”
Tettaton knows how to reproduce those vintage signs; he painted a smoky old mirror to look like it had been done in the late 1800s. He painted an old grain silo in Glen Carbon (now a garden center) to look like a stone castle tower, complete with trompe l’oeuil architectural ornament on the windows. On the North Side, he painted Jackson Park as it would have looked at the turn of the century (“I had to do a lot of ad-libbing!”) He’s also a master of the ’40s and ’50s; for a sign on a Crown Candy Co. window, he “painted it old-fashioned” and added a girl (pony-tailed) and boy (crew-cut) beneath the letters. When he did reproduction work at the Lemp Grand Hall on Cherokee, he painted Gilded Age scrollwork and an emblem on the mirror, stepped back, and smiled. It looked original.
“I decided to have a party and invite sign painters and artists,” he says. “Nobody figured it out. We faked ’em out!” He chuckles. “I like a good spoof.”
His own favorite sign is someone else’s masterwork, a mural outside a bar on South Jefferson that gives the illusion that some of the bricks are crumbling away, and a shotglass is bursting out of the wall.
For a time, he used quarts of oil paint, so he could get just the right purples and ambers for 3-M billboards, mixing and mixing without muddying them. Mainly, though, he’s always used oil-based enamel, adding linseed oil until it flowed like ink and glowed like it was lit from beneath.
He’s worked in every part of St. Louis, under every condition. He once misspelled Chevrolet (Chevorlet) on a huge sign on top of the old Placke Chevrolet dealer at Kingshighway and Southwest. As he finished the long, complicated job and wearily wiped his hands, he looked down and saw that a crowd had gathered: sales staff, office workers, mechanics. “Here, it’s right here, on the front of the car,” somebody yelled helpfully. “That’s how you spell it!”
But the hardest job was a tiny logo on the glass door of a Mexicana Airlines office in Clayton. The glass was 3/4 of an inch thick, and he was painting from the inside, with the pattern taped to the outside. “Every time I laid my brush down, the pattern was 3/4 of an inch away! I had to look at an angle!”
So why do we still pay attention to signs, when they wallpaper our world?
Because they’re compelling. “A sign is either pleasing to the eye, or it offends the eye,” Tettaton notes. “It identifies and directs. You pick up feelings from it.”
Lonnie Tettaton Fine Hand-Painted Signs is one of the last of its kind. There are still signs, signs, everywhere signs. But today, they are vinyl. And for the billboards Tettaton used to hand-paint, dizzy-high on scaffolding, until he had a crick in his neck—there are computer-generated wraps. “The artwork’s good,” he says slowly. “They can do all kinds of things with it. But—” He hesitates. “There’s a certain flair you can do with hand-painting.”
He did break down and start selling vinyl signs, though. Grudgingly.
“I don’t like it at all,” he blurts. “There’s a kid working for me, he does all the vinyl. I don’t even know how to run the machine.”
He knows gold leaf, though, and he still orders it in large quantities from New York. People who want something more personal still commission him. “The fellow who taught me, E.C. Matthews? I went back and saw him later, and he said, ‘Well, how did it go?’ I said, ‘Pretty good.’ He said, ‘It’s a good thing you didn’t know you can’t do gold leaf in this weather, ’cause the window sweats.’”
Tettaton laughs, hard. He didn’t know it was impossible. And he didn’t know it would end.