Founded in 1972, Duff’s was one of the legendary restaurants the late critic Joe Pollack dubbed the “Class of ’72,” a group of four restaurants that, according to Pollack, forever elevated the level of dining in St. Louis (the others being Balaban’s, Jefferson Avenue Boarding House, and Anthony’s).
After 41 years in business, current owners Karen Duffy and Tim Kirby have decided to close the landmark restaurant at 392 N. Euclid, an address that in earlier days, according to longtime customer and SLM dining critic Ann Lemons Pollack, was, besides Balaban’s, “the place to be in that part of town.”
Find the best food in St. Louis
Subscribe to the St. Louis Dining In and Dining Out newsletters to stay up-to-date on the local restaurant and culinary scene.
When asked why that was so, Pollack recalls that Duff’s was “exotic enough for people from out of town, but not too fancy for folks from Potosi…the all-things-to-all-people restaurant of its day.” Mismatched chairs and tables helped contribute to Duffs’ charm and appeal.
Original watercolor by Marilynne Bradley
From its inception, Duff’s was as involved with being a good community citizen as it was with feeding members of the community. Frequent customer Charlie Downs recalls that “Monday night was poetry night,” and in that regard “Duff’s was way ahead of its time.” Pollack recalled a specific Monday night, in the winter, when author Glenn Savan was reading from his book White Palace (the movie was later filmed in St. Louis). “It was a special night,” Pollack recalled. “The place was jammed, and it was raining, but the Christmas lights were still up.” When we discovered Dennis Dixson’s photo (at right), we knew exactly how she felt.
It became a meeting place for every author and poet that lived in or visited St. Louis, according to Pollack: ”I remember the Landesmans and Ron Powers offering to help out Bill McClellan’s kid, who worked there,” she recalls, “and the many nights they hosted dinners to support Agnes Wilcox’s classes for PPA [Prison Performing Arts, a literacy program that serves area correctional institutions].”
Brendan Kirby, Tim’s son and Duff’s GM, echoed Duffs’ ongoing community involvement and its importance in the rebirth of the CWE. And that Duff’s was not a concept, or theme restaurant, as is so common today. He noted that some staffers have logged decades of service, “so it’s just as much a family as it is a business,” and that he will “miss this family, and I know I won’t be alone.”
Indeed.
Pollack recalls that it was Duff’s that provided her first croque monsieur. Downs says, “The reuben is as good as any I’ve ever had,” adding, “That’s true for the Bloody Marys, too. Barrett’s Bloodys were so good, we eventually begged her for the long list of ingredients in her mix… We bought them all, but could never duplicate the taste.”
Downs, who also sold restaurant equipment to Duff’s longtime chef, Jimmy Voss, said that “in his 35 years there, Voss knew more local farmers than any chef today and was involved with locavorism before anybody even knew what that was.”
As soon as final terms get negotiated, the purchaser of the business and a portion of the building will be Brant Baldanza’s investment group, the folks responsible for two Corner Pub & Grill locations, The Tavern Kitchen & Bar, and The Shack, which opened in midtown last year. As Baldanza intends to open one restaurant a year, 392 N. Euclid appears the likely contender for 2013.
With Duff’s planning to close sometime at the end of this month, Baldanza’s group could begin renovations as early as mid-July. For details on exactly what’s planned for the space, check back on Relish later today.
Editor’s note: Future plans for the Duff’s space may be found in this post.