News / ‘A shock to us’: Senate Square tenants face eviction if they don’t leave in 17 days

‘A shock to us’: Senate Square tenants face eviction if they don’t leave in 17 days

Residents of the troubled Benton Park complex were given just two weeks to get out, or face eviction, under a letter sent last Friday.

The temporary owners of embattled Benton Park apartment complex Senate Square ordered residents on Friday to get out in 17 days—or face eviction.

The tenants aren’t alleged to have violated their lease. According to the letter they received Friday, they’re being forced out for “repairs.” But the timing, coming as it does in the midst of the Thanksgiving season, has some residents stressed out. They also question whether such a short notice to vacate is even legal when they were under leases that ran for many more months.

Get a fresh take on the day’s top news

Subscribe to the St. Louis Daily newsletter for a smart, succinct guide to local news from award-winning journalists Sarah Fenske and Ryan Krull.

We will never send spam or annoying emails. Unsubscribe anytime.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Tenant Ethan Shepard, who’s lived in Senate Square since late last year, just signed a lease for another year in October, which seemingly extended his stay at Senate Square until December of 2027, according to a lease viewed by SLM.

Shepard got the news Friday just before a previously planned hunting trip for much of this week. Given the upcoming holiday, and the short notice, he’s struggling to figure out his next move.

“They can’t do this, man, I’m not going to have anywhere to go,” Shepard says.

Senate Square is a collection of 30 historic rowhouses that were carved into 100 units decades ago. The complex long coexisted easily among the neighboring owner-occupied homes. But complaints from both residents and neighbors have multiplied after the complex was purchased by out-of-state ownership in 2022. After the owners defaulted on their mortgage payments, lender Arbor Realty SR set and then canceled multiple auctions amid a legal battle for control. The lender has appointed a receiver to manage the properties in the meantime.

That receiver, Trigild, is the one now ordering tenants to move out. The letter—which multiple tenants shared with SLM—is addressed to “CURRENT RESIDENTS.” Notably, one tenant told SLM Monday they received no such notice, but saw an online post about it from another resident and was unsure of its validity. 

Regardless, the letter specifies that it is meant to affect all residents.

“It is with regret that we inform you that the Senate Square Apartment community will be closing for repairs,” the letter reads. “All residents are required to vacate their apartments no later than November 30, 2026. Failure to vacate by this deadline will result in management submitting an eviction request.”

Alderwoman Jami Cox Antwi, who has been vocal about the problems at Senate Square, says the letter is “a shock to us.” She’s flagged the matter to the city’s legal team for investigation.

“It honestly stunned us,” she says. “Typically under Missouri law you need one month’s notice to terminate a lease. Seventeen days is not a month.”

The letter sent to residents comes from Andy Afshari, with a firm called Peak Properties (the management company under Trigild) listed as the property manager. Neither Afshari, nor a local attorney for the lender in the receivership case, responded to questions from SLM on Monday.

The letter says that tenants must provide Afshari with a forwarding address before they leave in order to receive their security deposit, provided they have proof they paid one. If they move out before the 30th, it continues, their credit will not be impacted, nor will they have a negative mark on their rental history—suggesting anyone who doesn’t comply could suffer those things. The letter also says tenants should contact Afshari for potential “assistance with relocation.”

Shepard, the resident who just signed a new lease last month, shared the notice he received on social media, asking for advice and questioning its legality. Shepard and his two brothers—who he’s quite close with—have few complaints about their unit at Senate Square, save for some minor maintenance issues.

Shepard says he’s trying to get in touch with organizations that could help him, but worries because he’ll be away from reliable cell service for much of the week. He says the 17-day notice puts him in a “crippling position.”

“This is impossible for me to be gone by November 30,” Shepard emailed Peak Properties, asking for assistance with relocation. “17 day notice doesn’t seem very legal.”

Someone from Peak replied within the hour, giving him a list of resources, to which Shepard replied: “None of them can help me relocate in 17 days.”

The Peak representative then told Shepard to use the city’s resources for displaced tenants for help. The staffer continued by saying that they “understand the timeframe is challenging,” but wrote that the City of St. Louis has programs for “displaced residents,” and could potentially help him further. 

A copy of the lease Shepard signed around six weeks ago, which someone familiar with landlord-tenant law describes as “boilerplate,” contained some stipulations that may apply here. If the landlord believes the apartment or complex is damaged and needs repairs that would require tenant relocation for more than 60 days, it says the owners may provide written notice to vacate.

The lease also says that if the buildings are set to be demolished, or will go offline for more than six months, the landlord can terminate the lease with 30 days’ written notice. (The letter Friday merely says that Senate Square will be closing for repairs.)

Those leases were signed under prior management, and it’s not exactly clear what, if any, legal obligation the receivers have to earlier tenants and their leases. However, it’s indisputable that the tenants have been given less than 30 days’ notice.

Shepard says his family has been through hardship lately. He and his brothers lost both of their parents and another brother in the past few years. They also experienced serious problems with their last apartment, and the recent developments at Senate Square are giving him “deja vu,” Shepard says. 

“We’re genuine just, like, good boys, for real,” Shepard’s brother, Elijah, chimes in.

Shepard adds that he recently got promoted at his job. He’s now the manager at a grocery store meat counter, a promising upswing in his life. Moving into Senate Square last year also felt like an upgrade. 

“I hate that I gotta move,” he says. Of his apartment, he continues, “It’s in decent shape, you know, I mean, things are old, but the fridge was new and the stove was new, so we appreciated that. And, we grew up poor, man, so we’re not used to, you know, luxury. So, when we got in there it’s like, it was pretty cool.

“You could write that I feel terrible about it. I’m severely stressed, nauseous, and it’s all true, man. I’m up against it, dude.”