Some lads there are, ’tis shame to say,
That only court to thieve,
Stay up-to-date with the local arts scene
Subscribe to the weekly St. Louis Arts+Culture newsletter to discover must-attend art exhibits, performances, festivals, and more.
And once they bear the bloom away
’Tis little enough they leave.
—A.E. Housman
Friday night’s performance of Don Giovanni at Union Avenue Opera—a company I knew little about—was a delight. Scott Schoonover, who formed the opera company in 1995, debuted with Purcell’s Dido and Aeneas. U.A.O. has continued to showcase works that garner critical acclaim, as well as keeping audiences spellbound and entertained.
Mozart’s opera, which premiered at the Teatro di Praga on October 29, 1787, takes place in Seville in the mid-18th century. And I was pleased to find myself in the gorgeous and comfortable Union Avenue Christian Church, the sun setting beyond stained-glass windows just as the performance was about to begin. I had spent the previous week listening to recordings of Don Giovanni, and was eager to hear U.A.O.’s orchestra perform Mozart’s famous overture—written hurriedly a day or two before the 1787 debut—which sounded as powerful as the records I’d been playing.
I think H.L. Menken said that “opera in English is like baseball in Italian,” a statement some might agree with. For the Menkenian in you, U.A.O. performed Don Giovanni in Italian, with English subtitles to the sides of the stage that featured eerie figures of fates that moved from time to time, given the specific scene.
Don Giovanni, the licentious nobleman fated to perish, is played perfectly by Galen Scott Bower. Bower’s voice is powerful, controlled. He comes across as a debauchee—as is expected—but one that commands the stage. Don Giovanni has been in as many women’s beds as there are stars in the visible sky. He’s heaped lie upon lie in order to juggle them, as it were. His trusty and humorous servant, Leporello, played brilliantly by Neil Nelson, often leads his master away from what seems like immanent ruin. But Leporello can only serve in this capacity for so long.
After murdering Don Pedro in a duel, Giovanni escapes with the help of his servant. Donna Anna, played by Amy Murray, a breathtakingly great soprano, vows revenge for the sudden death of her father. Her fiancé, Don Ottavio, agrees to see to it that justice is carried out. Ottavio is played by Anthony Webb, a fantastic singer and stage performer who radiates a certain justiciarii domini, carrying a full heart and a quick sword.
Don Giovanni gets caught up with Zerlina—played marvelously by the beautiful Karina Brazas—who is betrothed to Masetto, a “rube” as the libretto has it. Masetto is played by E. Scott Levin, again, convincingly and beautifully. Donna Elvira, a woman with whom Don Giovanni has inevitably taken up with and who haunts each scene with a pure voice and a strong presence, played by Gina Galati, took my breath away. Although the entire cast comes together to see to it that Don Giovanni is killed, the rake isn’t fated to die that way. The conclusion to this opera is subtle and unexpected.
I can only say that Union Avenue Opera is something I feel slightly ashamed to have not known. As I write and listen to old recordings of the Don Giovanni—certainly matched by U.A.O.’s entire cast—a newer feeling of gratitude sets in. This is world-class opera right here in St. Louis, performed in Italian. I can only hope for those of you who haven’t (yet) attended this season, you will give yourself no excuse to not witness Don Giovanni. I have often dreaded having to gripe about so many things. And I think it’s far more difficult to find beauty in this world, day by day. Friday night’s performance at Union Avenue Opera flies in the face of cynicism and coarseness, even though the theme is that of the man who “courts to thieve.” When I left the church on Union Avenue, it was late and dark and I was grateful to not only be alive but to feel so.
Don Giovanni runs through July 18 at Union Avenue Christian Church, 733 Union. For more information or to purchase tickets, call 314-361-2881, or go to unionavenueopera.org.