Food Fight: Italian Restaurants 2025

Presented by Underdog
St. Louis offers an impressive array of fantastico Italian restaurants. Help SLM decide which are our readers’ favorites! To start, we’ve listed 64 spots. Vote for your favorites during 6 rounds to help crown the winner. When you vote, you’ll be entered for the chance to win a $100 gift card to the winning restaurant courtesy of Underdog; plus, Underdog merch. Mangia!

This promotion has ended. Congratulations to Trattoria Marcella!