Editor's Note: These picks were chosen by our readers in an online ballot between February 29 and April 16 via stlmag.com. Only the number one picks were published in print.
» Albert Pujols, Illustration by Monica Hellstrom
Athlete
5. Chris Carpenter
4. Matt Holliday
3. TJ Oshie
2. Yadier Molina
1. Albert Pujols
